Cakeworthy Reviews

Cakeworthy has an overall rating of 4.2 based on 71 reviews. Customer feedback on Cakeworthy is mixed: Cakeworthy reviewers highlight positive aspects like wide variety of cakes, excellent customer service, timely delivery, which strongly appeal to cake enthusiasts, event planners, gift buyers. However, Cakeworthy is often criticized for its higher price point, limited customization options, occasional delivery issues.

4.2/5.0

71 reviews

5 Stars

9

4 Stars

7

3 Stars

5

2 Stars

0

1 Star

1

All Cakeworthy Reviews (71)
isobel-Craig
May 28, 2026
"Okay supplies, but limited options"
They had some decent cake supplies and I was able to find a few of the basic things I needed, but the selection felt limited. I was hoping for more styles and sizes to choose from. The experience was fine overall, but I did feel a little talked down to when I asked questions, which made it less enjoyable. Not terrible, just kind of average if you’re looking for a lot of options
jack-Williams
May 24, 2026
"Way easier tracking than I’m used to"
I ordered from cakeworthystore.com the tracking was much easier to follow than with a lot of other places I’ve bought from. I got an update when it shipped, and I could actually see where my order was without having to keep guessing or refresh a bunch of random pages. Everything was straightforward, and the package showed up right when they said it would. Overall, it was a smooth experience.
WilliamSolano
May 17, 2026
"Arrived Right on Time"
My order showed up right on schedule, and everything went smoothly. No issues at all. I’m guessing they’ve got their shipping process well sorted out, because it was a really easy experience.
Quentin-lee
May 15, 2026
"It arrived fine, packaging was just okay"
My order from cakeworthystore.com showed up in one piece, so no real complaints there... but the packaging felt kinda cheap tbh. The box had a few dents and the tape was a little loose, which didn’t make the best impression. Nothing was damaged though, so that’s a plus. I just thought it would be packed a bit better. Not terrible, just average for me
dana1972
April 12, 2026
"Pretty happy with how it turned out"
The cake design came out really close to what I asked for. Like, not 100% perfect if I’m being picky, but it still looked really nice and had its own original feel to it. Overall, I was happy with it.
Viola_miranda99
April 02, 2026
"The fabric is so soft and comfy it’s…"
The fabric is so soft and comfy it’s actually ridiculous. I put it on and immediately questioned why everything I own isn’t made out of this material. Total comfort overload in the best way.
hello_marjorie418
March 30, 2026
"Easy and useful site for baking supplies"
I used cakeworthystore.com while looking for a few baking items, and overall it was easy to use. The categories were simple to find, pages loaded without any issues, and the checkout process was clear. A couple of product pages felt a little crowded, so I had to scroll around more than I expected, but it wasn’t a big problem. It’s a useful site and I’d be happy to use it again...
Frances_owen85
March 02, 2026
"Finally Found It in Stock!"
I looked around at a few different places, and cakeworthystore.com was the one that actually had what I needed in stock :) Ordering was super easy too. it’s just nice not having to sit around waiting for restocks!
hello_james359
February 24, 2026
"I had a good feeling they’d…"
I had a good feeling they’d be helpful, and I’m glad I trusted my instinct. Support got back to me really quickly and made the whole thing easy
WillieBornstein
February 22, 2026
"I ordered my usual size, and to…"
I ordered my usual size, and to be fair, it fit just right. No surprises or sizing issues for me, which I really appreciate.
Nolan-nawfel
February 21, 2026
"Checkout was easy compared to most sites"
Ordering from cakeworthystore.com was straightforward. I found what I needed without much digging, and the cart updated normally, which already puts it ahead of some other sites I’ve used where the cart randomly glitches.

The checkout part was quick too. The payment steps were clear, and I didn’t have to go back and correct a bunch of stuff like I’ve had to do on other online stores, so that was a nice change.
I’m giving it 4 stars because one page did load a little slowly for me. It wasn’t a huge problem, especially compared to worse checkout experiences I’ve had, but I did notice it.
BenjaminHarrison_17
February 14, 2026
"Showed Up Shockingly Fast"
It got here way faster than I expected, which was a nice surprise for once. Shipping was quick and there were no issues, so I guess miracles do happen.
Kathryn.curb
February 08, 2026
"Easy preorder, no issues"
I preordered a cake and everything went really smoothly. It was ready right on time, and I didn’t have to deal with any hassle. Definitely something I’d recommend if you want to keep things simple
LEJEUNE
February 07, 2026
"When I first opened it, I was…"
When I first opened it, I was actually excited because it looked really nice and made a good first impression. I thought it was going to be exactly what I wanted. But once I tried it, the texture just felt a little dry to me, and that kind of took away from the experience. It wasn’t terrible, just not as smooth or comfortable as I was expecting.
charles_Strawder87
February 04, 2026
"I really liked having different payment options to..."
I really liked having different payment options to choose from. Compared to a lot of other places where checkout feels rushed or limited, this made the whole process way less stressful and more convenient...
HANSEN
January 14, 2026
"Everything showed up right"
My order came in just as expected, and nothing was missing, which was nice to see. One pack was a little bent, but it wasn’t a big deal. Overall, I’m happy with how it turned out.
bobby.Pride
January 06, 2026
"Return took a little while"
The return process took a bit longer than I expected, I think, but it did get sorted in the end.
CRISS
December 19, 2025
"Print held up really well"
I got a printed cake topper from cakeworthystore.com for my son’s birthday and it turned out nice. The print looked clear and didn’t fade or smudge, even after it sat out for awhile. One corner was a little bent when it showed up, but it wasn’t a big deal and you could barely notice it on the cake. Overall I was happy with how durable it was and I’d probaly order again
joy_Galvan05
December 13, 2025
"Decent size range, but I definitely wish there were more options"
The size range is okay overall, and I did notice that there are at least some different sizes to choose from, which is nice. That said, I kind of expected there to be a few more options available, especially for people who might fall between the standard sizes or need something a little more specific. It’s not terrible by any means, and you might still find what you need, but I do think the selection could be better and a bit more inclusive.
AshleyBridges_29
December 10, 2025
"Fits Fine, But Not the Best for Long Wear"
It fits okay overall, like the sizing isn’t really the problem and it doesn’t feel wrong when I first put it on. But after wearing it for a few hours, I definitely start noticing that it could be more comfortable. It’s not unbearable or anything, and I can still use it, but it’s the kind of thing where at first you think it’s fine, and then later you realize you keep adjusting it or just feeling slightly annoyed by it. So basically, decent fit, but comfort could be better if you’re planning to wear it for a long stretch

View More Reviews

Cakeworthy Q&A

Cakeworthy as a company has gone exceedingly downhill. I say this as someone who spent thousands of dollars in store with them and on their website. I had one issue, complained and asked for a manager, and instead they deleted and blocked my account, and deleted over $150 in Rewards I had saved up. They then did this to my Rewards and just laughed instead of trying to solve the problem. Check out TrustPilot or google and you can see how awful their customer service is. AVOID! AVOID! AVOID!

Have a question about Cakeworthy?

Customer Reviews

Questions & Answers

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.